Harley-Davidson: Mediocre or Legend?
Harley-Davidson is the American dream on two wheels. The sound, the chrome, the open road. The brand has been selling that dream for more than 120 years, and here in Canada you see them everywhere in the summer. But since 2024, the dream has taken a hit. Between Transport Canada and the NHTSA (the U.S. road safety agency), Harley has racked up 20 recall notices. Twenty, for a brand that calls itself the benchmark. So I’m asking the question: has Harley become mediocre?
A quick disclaimer first: I’ve never owned a Harley. I rode a Kawasaki Concours for 16 years and I’m now on a BMW GS. I’ve got nothing against Harley, but nothing to defend either!
The recalls: a closer look
Transport Canada has published 11 Harley recall notices since 2024: 4 in 2024, 4 in 2025 and 3 in 2026. In the U.S., the NHTSA has opened 9 campaigns: 3 in 2024, 2 in 2025 and 4 in 2026. That’s 20 notices.
But careful: several of them cover the same problem, once in Canada and once in the U.S. The Sportster S upper triple clamp, the rear brake line on the Heritage Classic, Street Bob and Low Rider, the airbox on the Street Glide, Road Glide, Fat Boy and Breakout: each time, one defect, two notices. Take out the duplicates and you’re still looking at at least eight different defects. That’s fewer than 20, but it’s still a lot.
And some details bother me. The Sportster S triple clamp had to be fixed twice, because the first repair, in 2025, wasn’t enough. The Softail rear shock (82,117 bikes in the U.S.) had already been repaired once in 2023. And the latest one, the gear position sensor on 2026 Touring models (21,643 bikes in the U.S.): the dash can show “N” while the bike is in gear, and Harley reports two injuries possibly linked to it. At the time of writing, there’s still no matching recall from Transport Canada. (I wrote about it here.)
Sales are melting away
While the recalls pile up, sales keep dropping. Harley sold 194,256 new motorcycles worldwide in 2021. In 2025: 132,535. That’s almost a third fewer in four years, including a 12% drop in 2025 alone.
Every region is down: -13% in North America, -11% in Europe, the Middle East and Africa, -15% in Asia-Pacific. The company’s revenue fell 14% in 2025, and the motorcycle division lost US$29 million (about C$40 million). For 2026, Harley expects to sell 130,000 to 135,000 motorcycles, roughly the same as 2025. No comeback in sight.
A question of scale
The world buys around 50 million two-wheelers a year (motorcycles and scooters). Honda alone sold 20.6 million between April 2024 and March 2025, a record. Do the math: Honda sells more two-wheelers in two and a half days than Harley does in a year! Harley is about 0.3% of the world market. It’s not playing in the same league.
To be fair, Harley still rules at home. In the U.S., it still holds more than a third of the market for motorcycles over 600 cc (34.5% in 2025). But even there, it’s slipping: it was 37.3% in 2024. The dream isn’t dead down there. But it’s a big fish in a shrinking pond, while the rest of the world rides something else.
So, mediocre?
The recalls also show the system works: defects get found, repairs are free and owners are notified. That’s not the problem. The problem is how often it happens. Eight different defects in three years, including one repair that had to be redone, raises questions about quality control at the factory.
Add sales down by a third in four years and barely 0.3% of the world market, and the picture is pretty clear. Harley didn’t become a bad brand overnight. But the American dream is shrinking. The real question isn’t whether Harley is mediocre anymore. It’s whether it can become what it once was.
What do you think? If you own a Harley, were you affected by any of these recalls?
To check whether your bike is under a recall, enter your VIN in Transport Canada’s recall database.
Ride safe!
Photos
Main photo: a Harley-Davidson Touring bike at the Hogs for Hospice rally in Leamington, Ontario. Photo: Chris Woodrich, August 2, 2025, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Sources
- Transport Canada, Recalls and safety alerts (notices 2024-533, 2024-608, 2024-734, 2024-756, 2025-187, 2025-311, 2025-312, 2025-486, 2026-064, 2026-191, 2026-216)
- NHTSA, recalls (campaigns 24V672, 24V719, 24V753, 25V375, 25V590, 26V075, 26V234, 26V270, 26V730)
- Harley-Davidson, worldwide retail sales 2021-2025
- Harley-Davidson, 2025 results and 2026 outlook, February 10, 2026
- Paul Tan, Honda sells 20.57 million two-wheelers (fiscal 2025)
- Autocar Professional, global two-wheeler market according to Honda
- Harley-Davidson, 2025 annual report (Form 10-K), U.S. 601+cc market share